|
Articles and whitepapers
26/8/2003
Light Up Your Cable: A Quick Way To Identify Cable
Runs
By John W Aldous
There are two aspects of a premise wiring system that can cause
significant cost in both time and efficiency.
The first is the time taken to identify the cable runs from outlet
to the patch panel after the cable has been installed. Unlike equipment
costs, which are relatively fixed, the cost of installation can
change depending on the time and the cost of labour. Ask any cable
installer who has had the experience of pulling bundles of cable
through small areas to the communications room, what the most time-consuming
part of their job is, and the answer is always the same - it's the
long process of identifying each cable with its workstation.
The second is the maintenance of the system such that the ports
are still identified and the patch cord ends can easily and quickly
be identified. How many installations' records have deteriorated
over time, or are so poorly completed that a major problem is encountered
when changes become necessary?
Solutions
Current methods are often frustrating. A
tone generator can transmit crosstalk over eight other cables, and
cable tags often fall off while being pulled through tight spaces,
and can be easily incorrectly marked. The concept of using light
to identify cables is not new. Cabling contractor Willam C. Fincher
and his son Randy have been using LED lights in the form of modular
plugs to identify cables, for some time. On one very large job,
their firm, SCCI, saved three weeks of labour cost using their 'home-made'
cable locator plugs. A patent was granted in 1998, and the technology
is sold as the DataLite System kit.
This kit includes a number of modular plugs
with LEDs built-in. During installation, there is no need to label
the cables before pulling and termination. Instead, the installer
inserts these modular plugs into each port of the patch panels.
Another installer would then use a power unit at the 'far end' to
send power from the workstation to light up one of the LED modular
plugs, thus identifying the port connected to that workstation.
LEDs built into the Patch Panel
Although the DataLite System offers a solution
for identifying cables on a traditional patch panel, installers
must still place the LED plugs into each of the patch panel ports,
and may find themselves short of plugs in a large installation job.
A new patent-pending solution, developed by Aldous Systems in cooperation
with the patent licensee, places the LED onto the patch pane, and
is called LCI (Light Cable Identification) technology.
Figure 1 - Identifying cable using LCI technology built into the
patch panel
How it works
Very much like the DataLite System, patch
panels with LCl technology give installers the freedom to begin
pulling cables from workstations without having to label them. Installers
can finish pulling all the cables to the communications room before
starting the job of identifying them. This offers installers a more
organised working environment because debris and obstacles can be
cleaned away as the actual installation work is completed. To identify
the cables, one worker simply walks from one workstation to the
next plugging in the signal sender to the outlet and communicating
via radio to the second installer in the communications room. The
second installer identifies which LED on the patch panel lights
up, records the connection, and the step is repeated.
Problems with existing methods
Tone Generators
For decades, phone technicians and electricians
have been using tone generators to quickly locate and identify phone
lines and other electrical wiring. This method has been carried
over to LAN cabling and, although it has been an acceptable practice
for years, it does not work with the Cat5e and Cat6 network cable
developed to support high bitrates. With these, cable pairs must
be so precisely balanced and tuned at the higher frequencies in
order to block noise at lower frequencies, that the lower tone generator
frequencies are forced to the far-end as cross-talk across as many
as eight other cables. Without actually touching the probe on the
copper wire, it is nearly impossible to select the correct cable
at the far end.
Labelling Cables
Cabling training instructors realised the
problem several years ago and started teaching a method of tagging
or marking the far end of the network cables prior to the pull through
small spaces to the communications room. This is a time-consuming
process that must be carried out with a tremendous amount of care.
The tags must be marked correctly with the proper workstation designation,
and attached securely - otherwise, problems and confusion will result
at the far end.
Further problems arise when contractors hire
helpers or trainees to do the time-consuming work of marking cables,
thus increasing the chance of mis-marked tags or tags coming off
during the pull. Then, in order to start sequentially punching down
the cable to the corresponding patch panel port as instructed in
the training class, the cabling technician must find number '1'
out of hundreds, or even over a thousand, lines. All of that time
spent sequentially punching down the cable will be wasted later
when additions, changes or moves are implemented and thus destroy
the sequence.
Performance
Although one would think that, with an LED
built into a passive device, the performance would be affected,
tests show that the performance of patch panels with and without
LCI technology are virtually identical, as shown in the charts and
table below.
Figure 2 - Insertion Loss Comparison between Patch Panels with and
without LCI technology
Figure 3 - NEXT Comparison between Patch Panels with and without
LCI technology
| Headroom Without LCI Technology |
| Cat6 |
Connecting hardware Insertion Loss: |
0.11dB |
| Cat6 |
Permanent Link Return Loss: |
3.0dB |
| Cat6 |
Permanent Link NEXT: |
3.7dB |
| Headroom With LCI Technology |
| Cat6 |
Connecting hardware Insertion Loss: |
0.10dB |
| Cat6 |
Permanent Link Return Loss: |
3.8dB |
| Cat6 |
Permanent Link NEXT: |
3.3dB |
Table 1 - Cable headroom with and without LCI
Technology
The test configuration for both the Return
Loss and NEXT were setup according to the TIA-EIA-568-B.2-1 final
specifications utilising 90 meters of Cat6 horizontal cables. The
test equipment used was an HP 8152C Network Analyser. In each test,
the performances of the patch panel with and without LCI technology
are identical within tolerance, and both easily exceeded Cat6 requirements.
How much time and money is actually saved?
Because patch panels with LCI technology
are not yet available, a documented case history of the DataLite
System can be used instead, due to the similarities of its usage.
It should be remembered that the DataLite System is used on standard
patch panels, and so requires the extra step of inserting the modular
LED plugs. The time saving of using patch panels with LCI technology
therefore, would be even greater.
Table 2 shows data obtained by Structured
Communications Cabling at Harris Hospital where cables are installed
to 500 workstations.
| Identifying cables using a tone
generator |
24 ports per patch panel
x3 minutes to identify each cable
x2 workers
divide by 60 minutes/hour
x£25 per hour wage
= £60 labour to identify cables per patch panel |
| Identifying cables using LED technology |
24 ports per patch panel
x0.5 minutes to identify each cable
x2 workers
divide by 60 minutes/hour
x£25 per hour wage
= £10 labour to identify cables per patch panel |
Table 2 - comparison of cable identification
costs using a tone generator and LED technology
The above example shows that using LED technology
results in a cost saving of £50 per patch panel. In some cases,
this is more than half the cost of the patch panel. The cost of
the patch panel with LCI technology is on average approximately
20% above the conventional panel cost, but this is more than compensated
for in the potential cost savings.
Patch Cords Identification
To remove this problem permanently, the simple
use of light technology can be used to identify ends of patch cords.
How many installers or end-users have experienced difficulty and
frustration in identifying patch cord ends where the labels have
been damaged or are missing, and they are installed in a high density?
By the use of a fibre optic 'loop' integrated into the patch cord,
this problem is removed permanently. The principle of the PatchSee
system can be see in Figure 4.
Figure 4 - the PatchSee System for identifying patch cord ends
The use of the specially-designed torch provides
the light transmission into one end of the RJ45 plug. The other
end of the patch cord is very easily identified by the twin spots
of light showing on the rearward face of the plug. This innovative
product contributes added value to both the installer and the end
user.
Summary
LCI technology brings significant benefits
to installers and end users of premise cabling systems, by offering
significant savings in terms of time and money, both during the
installation and beyond. It makes cable identification easy and
error-free, and has no adverse effects on cable performance.
John W Aldous is Managing Director of Aldous Systems
(Europe) Ltd.
www.aldoussystems.co.uk
|